The Princess In The Pantry contains affiliate links and is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. If you make a purchase using one of these Amazon links, we may receive compensation at no extra cost to you. See our disclosure policy for more information.

Buckeye Candy

Sharing is caring!

Buckeye Candy Recipe

Buckeye Candy is a beloved confectionary treat that has its roots in Ohio, United States. This delightful dessert gets its name from the resemblance of its shape to that of a buckeye seed – the nut of the Ohio state tree, the Buckeye tree.

Buckeye chocolates are made with a creamy peanut butter filling coated in chocolate, making it a delectable sweet and savory blend. Buckeyes are often enjoyed during holidays or special occasions and have become an iconic treat for many Midwesterners.

We’ll delve into the history and preparation of these classic chocolate candy balls, as well as exploring some delicious variations on this traditional recipe.

Buckeye Candy balls on a green and white checkered tablecloth.  A chocolate peanut butter ball recipe where creamy peanut butter balls are dipped in chocolate.

Where Did Buckeye Candy Originate

Buckeye candy is a sweet treat that has become an iconic dessert in the United States, particularly in Ohio. This candy consists of a peanut butter ball dipped in chocolate and resembles the nut from the buckeye tree. Although it’s unclear who first created this delicious confectionery, there are several theories about its origin.

One theory suggests that Buckeye candy was invented by early 20th-century Ohio State University students. According to this story, these students were inspired by the state tree of Ohio, which is the buckeye tree. They decided to make a peanut butter filling shaped like a buckeye nut and coat it with chocolate.

Another popular theory suggests that Buckeye desserts originated during the Great Depression era when ingredients were scarce. Peanut butter was one of the few affordable ingredients available at that time, and people would often mix it with sugar to make a simple yet tasty treat.

Regardless of its origins, Buckeye candy has become synonymous with Ohio and is often enjoyed during football games and other events throughout the state. It has also gained popularity outside of Ohio and can be found at specialty stores or made at home using various recipes.

Whatever the origins of this sweet treat are I am completely hooked on them and I hope that after one bite you will be too. Read on to learn how to make buckeye candy.

Buckeye Chocolates made from peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate.  Buckeye candies sitting on a white and green checkered tablecloth.  One buckeye candy is in the front and has a bite that has been taken out of it.

Why You’ll Love This Buckeye Candy

Homemade buckeyes are a sweet and delicious treat. They are made of a creamy peanut butter filling covered in chocolate to resemble the nut from the buckeye tree. Here are some reasons you’ll love this tasty confection:

  1. It’s irresistible: The combination of smooth peanut butter and rich chocolate is simply irresistible. Once you take a bite of Buckeye candy, it’ll be hard to stop at just one.
  2. Easy to make: With only a few simple ingredients, including peanut butter, powdered sugar, and chocolate chips, Buckeye candy is easy to make at home. You don’t need any special equipment or skills – just mix up the filling,

Buckeye Candy Recipe Ingredients

This recipe for buckeye candy only requires a few simple ingredients that most families have on hand. I also like to double the recipe and store some in the fridge to keep as a snack and highly recommend it.

INGREDIENTS  

Peanut Butter Balls

  • 2 1/2 Cup Powdered Sugar
  • 1 Cup Creamy Peanut Butter Do not use natural Peanut Butter
  • 6 Tablespoon Butter At Room Temperature
  • 1 teaspoon Pure Vanilla Extract
  • 1/8 teaspoon Salt

Chocolate Coating

  • 10 Ounces Melting Chocolate Wafers
  • 1/2 Cup Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips

EQUIPMENT

Here is a list of the items that I used to make these buckeye chocolates. I have included the link for some of my favorite items to make them easier for you to locate on amazon.

How To Make Buckeye Candy

Line a baking sheet with parchment paper and set aside.

Using the mixer cream together the creamy peanut butter and butter until completely combined. This takes 2-3 minutes.

Beat into the mixture the Pure Vanilla Extract and the salt until they are completely combined. This takes about a minute.

The mixture should be creamy and resemble cake batter.

A glass bowl with creamy peanut butter in it showing the ingredients for a Buckeye Ball.  Picture is showing how to make buckeye candy peanut butter filling.

With the mixer on low speed add the powdered sugar 1/4 cup at a time. I like to stop the mixer and scrape the sides of the bowl a few times to ensure that all the ingredients mix together.

The finished peanut butter mixture should be smooth and a little crumbly but not sticky.

If it is too sticky add a bit more of the powdered sugar until it no longer sticks to your hands. It should be easy to roll into balls.

Buckeye Ball Recipe being made in a glass bowl using a wooden spoon.  The peanut butter buckeye mix is being formed with the peanut butter and powdered sugar.  This will be formed into balls to be the center of the homemade buckeyes.

Scoop the mixture out of the bowl and roll into small 1 inch sized balls. I use a wooden spoon to scoop up the peanut butter mixture and roll it into balls using my hands.

Place the peanut butter balls on the parchment lined baking sheet. Once all of the peanut butter balls have been formed place the baking sheet into a freezer for 30 minutes or into the refrigerator for 1 hour.

Because they are going to be dipped into warm chocolate we want to prevent them from melting.

Peanut butter balls should be firm to the touch not soft.

A cookie sheet with a piece of parchment paper with 18 peanut butter balls on it.  The peanut butter balls are being prepared to be the center of the Buckeye Candies.

Dipping Buckeye Candy In Chocolate

Add the semi-sweet chocolate chips and the chocolate melting wafers together into a microwave safe bowl. Heat them together in the microwave in 30 second increments until fully melted.

Remove the peanut butter balls from the freezer and use a toothpick to stick into the top of the peanut butter balls and transfer them to the melted chocolate.

Do not cover the entire peanut butter ball, but leave a small area uncovered on top.

Peanut Butter Buckeye Recipe being made.  Peanut butter balls being dipped into a warm pan of melted chocolate.  A toothpick is inserted into the peanut butter ball and is being used to coat the buckeye candy in chocolate.

Drain excess chocolate and transfer the chocolate covered peanut butter ball to the parchment paper lined baking sheet.

Careful remove the toothpick from the chocolate peanut butter ball and use your finger to close up the hole on top. Repeat the process with the remaining peanut butter balls until they are all covered with chocolate.

Place the buckeyes into the refrigerator until ready to serve and Enjoy!

Chocolate covered peanut butter balls sitting on parchment paper to cool.  Recipe showing how to make buckeye candy and allow the chocolate to firm up after dipping the buckeye desserts into chocolate.

Buckeye Candy Variations

The original recipe for buckeye is a delicious treat there are many ways that you could add to this recipe. The sweet and creamy peanut butter filling is the basis for these homemade buckeyes but feel free to throw some add-ins into the mix. Try using crushed nuts or pretzels to bring some crunch. Or change up the chocolate to bring in a different flavor. Here are some buckeye recipe variations to try.

White Chocolate Buckeyes

If you’re looking for a twist on the original recipe, try making white chocolate buckeyes instead. This version replaces the dark chocolate coating with smooth and creamy white chocolate, giving it a lighter and sweeter taste.

Nutella Buckeyes

For those who love all things Nutella, give this variation a try! It swaps out the traditional peanut butter filling for a rich and nutty Nutella-based one. That’s right you can use Nutella instead of the peanut butter option in these chocolate candy balls.

Oreo Buckeyes

Oreo lovers rejoice – this variation combines two beloved treats into one delightful mouthful! Simply replace some of the powdered sugar in the peanut butter filling with crushed Oreos for an extra crunchy texture.

Coconut Buckeyes

Coconut adds an exotic flair to these already tasty treats! Mix shredded coconut into your peanut butter filling or coat them in toasted coconut flakes for added flavor and texture to this buckeye dessert.

Caramel Buckeyes

Caramel adds another level of sweetness and richness to these candies! Drizzle caramel sauce over your finished buckeyes or add chopped caramel bits to your peanut butter mixture before shaping them.

Pretzel Buckeyes

Salty pretzels combined with sweet chocolate make for an irresistible snack! Crush up pretzels finely and mix them into your peanut butter mixture prior to coating them in chocolate. The pretzels bring a great crunch to these chocolate candy balls.

Close up image of a buckeye candy that has a bite taken out of it. The buckeye candy is being held in a persons hand close to the camera making it easy to see the creamy peanut butter filling.   In the background is finished chocolate candy balls from this Buckeye Ball Recipe sitting on parchment paper on a cookie sheet.

FAQs About Buckeye Candy

What does a buckeye taste like?

If you love the combination of chocolate and peanut butter then you will love buckeye candy. I find this recipe to taste similar to a Reese’s peanut butter cup.

Does This Buckeyes Candy Recipe Have To Be Refrigerated?

If you’ve just made homemade buckeyes or purchased them from a store, it’s best to refrigerate them. However, if you’re planning on serving this buckeye dessert recipe immediately or within a few hours of making them, then there’s no need to refrigerate them.

How do you keep buckeyes from sweating?

The best way to prevent buckeyes from sweating is to chill the dough before dipping it in chocolate and to refrigerate them after dipping. Keep them stored in the fridge until they are ready to be served for the best result.

How To Freeze Buckeye Chocolates

If you have a large batch of buckeye chocolate candy and don’t want to eat them all at once, you may be wondering if you can freeze them.

The good news is that yes, you can freeze buckeyes! However, there are some tips and tricks to keep in mind to ensure they stay fresh and tasty.

  1. Freeze buckeye candies as soon as possible: If you plan on freezing your buckeyes, it’s best to do so as soon as possible after making them. This will help maintain their texture and flavor.
  2. Use quality ingredients: When making buckeyes for freezing purposes, use high-quality ingredients. Cheap peanut butter or low-quality chocolate could result in an unpleasant taste or texture when thawed.
  3. Wrap each buckeye chocolate Individually: To prevent your buckeyes from sticking together when frozen, wrap each one individually in plastic wrap or wax paper before placing them in a freezer-safe container or bag.
  4. Label and date your container: Make sure to label your container with the date of freezing so that you know how long they’ve been stored in the freezer.
  5. Defrost slowly: When ready to enjoy your frozen buckeyes, defrost them slowly by moving the container from the freezer to the fridge for several hours before serving.
  6. Keep them fresh: Once thawed, store your buckeyes in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to two weeks maximum,

More Candy Recipes To Try

If you love candy like I do then here are some delicious option to add to your next candy making session.

  • Peanut Butter Fudge is a soft and creamy fudge with a peanut butter base. It is quick and easy to make and a family favorite in my home.
  • Orange Creamsicle Fudge is the perfect combination of orange and vanilla in fudge form.
  • Christmas Crack takes a foundation of saltine crackers and builds a caramel toffee layer followed by a chocolate ganache. The combination of sweet and salty makes this a holiday treat I like to have year round.
  • Graham Cracker Christmas Crack takes the basic Christmas crack recipe and elevates it with a cookie base made of graham crackers. The sweet cracker base followed by toffee then chocolate make a decadent treat.
  • Millionaire Shortbread combines a shortbread base with a soft caramel layer and a chocolate ganache topping. Perfect for those who like a detailed recipe and have a massive sweet tooth.
Buckeye Candy

Buckeye Candy

Buckeye Candy is a beloved confectionary treat that has its roots in Ohio, United States. This delightful dessert gets its name from the resemblance of its shape to that of a buckeye seed – the nut of the Ohio state tree, the Buckeye tree.
The candy is made with a creamy peanut butter filling coated in chocolate, making it a delectable sweet and savory blend. Buckeyes are often enjoyed during holidays or special occasions and have become an iconic treat for many Midwesterners.
Prep Time 30 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Course Dessert
Cuisine American

Equipment

  • 1 Medium Mixing Bowl
  • 1 Small Microwave Safe Bowl
  • 1 Wooden Mixing Spoon
  • 1 Baking Sheet
  • 1 Parchment Paper Sheets
  • 1 Handheld mixer or Standing Mixer

Ingredients
  

Peanut Butter Balls

  • 2 1/2 Cup Powdered Sugar
  • 1 Cup Creamy Peanut Butter Do not use natural Peanut Butter
  • 6 Tbsp Butter At Room Temperature
  • 1 tsp Pure Vanilla Extract
  • 1/8 tsp Salt

Chocolate Coating

  • 10 Ounces Melting Chocolate Wafers
  • 1/2 Cup Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips

Instructions
 

  • Line a baking sheet with parchment paper and set aside.
  • Using the mixer cream together the peanut butter and butter until completely combined. This takes 2-3 minutes.
    Beat into the mixture the Pure Vanilla Extract and the salt
  • With the mixer on low speed add the powdered sugar 1/4 cup at a time. I like to stop the mixer and scrape the sides of the bowl a few times to ensure that all the ingredients mix together.
    The finished peanut butter mixture should be smooth and a little crumbly but not sticky.
  • Scoop the mixture out of the bowl and roll into small 1 inch sized balls. Place the peanut butter balls on the parchment lined baking sheet.
    Once all of the peanut butter balls have been formed place the baking sheet into a freezer for 30 minutes or into the refrigerator for 1 hour.
    Peanut butter balls should be firm to the touch not soft.
  • Add the semi-sweet chocolate chips and the chocolate melting wafers together into a microwave safe bowl.
    Heat them together in the microwave in 30 second increments until fully melted.
  • Remove the peanut butter balls from the freezer and use a toothpick to stick into the top of the peanut butter balls and transfer them to the melted chocolate.
  • Do not cover the entire peanut butter ball, but leave a small area uncovered on top.
    Drain excess chocolate and transfer the chocolate covered peanut butter ball to the parchment paper lined baking sheet.
    Careful remove the toothpick from the Buckeye and use your finger to close up the hole on top.
    Repeat the process with the remaining peanut butter balls until they are all covered with chocolate.
  • Place the buckeyes into the refrigerator until ready to serve and Enjoy!
Keyword Buckeye Candy, Buckeye Candy Recipe, Buckeye Chocolates, Buckeye Dessert, Buckeye Desserts, Candy, Chocolate Candy Balls, Dessert, Homemade Buckeyes, How To Make Buckeye Candy, Milk Chocolate, Peanut Butter, Recipe For Buckeye Candy

Dessert Recipes

Here are a few more dessert recipes if you are looking for more Ideas: